Doubt is the beginning of wisdom

This wise quote is attributed to Aristotle. It should be above the entrance at the university. Students who are allowed to enter the ‘temple of wisdom’ on the basis of proven qualities would be reminded of what society expects of them.

According to Goethe, wisdom could only be found in truth. Unfortunately, universities are increasingly looking like publishing factories and fundraising institutions.

The reflective, investigative, teaching and inspiring professor of the past has often made way for managers who can sell research projects. The reputation of professors depends less and less on scientific excellence through innovative insights and ground-breaking discoveries. Nowadays, the amount of research money raised often determines the degree of success. Money is power and that power lies with the one who pays.

Finding the truth only thrives in an open and pluralistic environment where unbiased research can be conducted. Doubt encourages you to reconsider hypotheses, ask critical questions and think outside the usual box. Debate based on facts and substantiated arguments is ‘ good scientific practices ‘.

However, developments at universities are not moving towards plurality and openness, but are promoting one-sidedness. People with an opinion that deviates from the social norm have a difficult time. Renowned professors who present a substantiated opinion that is unwelcome are sometimes even banned from speaking engagements by the university management.

Doubting the prescribed narrative seems undesirable. One-sidedness of information provision characterizes the old media. The same professors invariably appear at national TV talk tables who, as self-appointed experts, mainly proclaim the government narrative . If they ever go out of line, they usually rush to correct it again, whether or not encouraged to do so from above.

This happened to Professor Ernst Kuipers of Erasmus UMC, for example, when he admitted to the camera that the curfew had no effect on the spread of the coronavirus. Scarce counter-narratives in the mainstream media are carefully framed with trained proclaimers of the desired story. A substantive debate with, for example, two proponents and two opponents of government policy that leaves a final decision to the viewer would be an enormous boost for the social debate.

It is alarming that open debate is also becoming increasingly difficult at universities. One-sidedness is apparently the new norm in our society. Universities in particular, as defenders of free speech and truth-finding, should take a stand against this unscientific and disastrous development. Unfortunately, universities even appear to go along with non-scientifically substantiated corona measures that sometimes violate our fundamental rights.

It is incomprehensible that universities would even consider denying admission to a large group of students based on their -completely personal- medical status. This means that the unlawful exclusion of large groups of people that disrupts our society also threatens our universities. Medical integrity is a fundamental right of every individual and the right to education should be sacred to the administrators of our ‘temples of wisdom’.

Fortunately, there is a growing group of students who are speaking out strongly against this unlawful admission requirement. Students from the Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam have founded the organization ‘VU in resistance’, as evidenced by this website. A courageous and commendable initiative that deserves widespread imitation among students and professors at this and other universities.

Students and academics must guard the truth and therefore the right to doubt with all their might. This is essential for the functioning of universities and their social role. Because as Bertrand Russell said : ‘The whole problem of the world is that fools and fanatics are always so certain of themselves, and wiser people so full of doubt.’

Dolf van Wijk, December 2021

This article appeared on the Students in Resistance website:


Latest Articles

Educational Vision Nova Academia

This is the textual version of a presentation, by Tjeerd Andringa, addressing the Educational Vision of Nova Academia during the Inaugural Day on April 6, 2024. Note: This text is

Read More »

Prof. Gigi Foster guest of Weekends

Professor Gigi Foster from our Academic Advisory Board, guest of Weekends with Jason Olbourne.
GUEST OVERVIEW: Gigi Foster is a US-born academic and economist. She is currently a professor of economics at the University of New South Wales. She regularly appears in the Australian media on the topic of economics, Foster received a Bachelor of Arts (Ethics, Politics, and Economics) from Yale University, and completed a PhD in economics at the University of Maryland. Gigi has been vocal about her views on government policies related to COVID-19. She is a founder of Australians for Science and Freedom an organisation aimed at promoting intellectual and personal freedom in public debate and public policy, including the analysis of scientific questions, and the transparency, contestability and accountability of public decision-making.

Read More »

Aan tafel bij Blckbx

Blckbx Kritische denkers opleiden in een Kasteel! Nova Academia trapt af…
Waar je ooit intellectueel werd uitgedaagd en verantwoordelijk volwassenen werd, bevinden universiteitsstudenten zich nu in grote onpersoonlijke bureaucratische systemen die je als kwetsbaar behandelen tegen verkeerd denken. Je leert volgzaamheid en dogma’s, waardoor je niet voorbereid bent op de eisen van werk en volwassenheid. Waarom je leven verspillen op zulke zielloze plekken als het ook anders kan?

Nova Academia in oprichting is gesitueerd in een sprookjesachtig kasteel in Wallonië (België), en de oprichters krijgen op 22 maart de sleutel om kritisch denkende mensen op te leiden voor de uitdagingen van morgen. ‘Wie zijn deze twee paradijsvogels? En wat zijn ze precies van plan?’ was de openingsvraag van programmamaker Flavio Pasquino, die de oprichters Dr. Erika Turkstra en Prof. dr. Paul Frijters interviewde over hun plannen en drijfveren.

De academie biedt een éénjarige opleiding aan waarbij met name economie en gezondheid centraal staan, naast een brede, holistische oriëntatie op de wereld als geheel. Intussen hebben veel docenten, uit binnen- en buitenland zich aangesloten. Waaronder ook vertrouwde namen als emeritus hoogleraar prof. dr. Kees van der Pijl.

Read More »

Dr. Tjeerd Andringa ‘What is Authority?’

Nova Academia’s Sample Teaching Sessions on the 2nd of March 2024

An interactive discussion-rich lecture by Dr Tjeerd Andringa on Truth, Authority, and the 6 levels of Mental Development. An example of how we teach at Nova Academia.

Read More »